Fausk said...
It is rather frequently that I get asked the question from friends and acquaintances, "What game should I buy?" Generally, my first response to them is to ask what genre they play. Unfortunately, I'm beginning to see how insignificant that question can be, especially in more recent times.
The clear genre distinctions we had from the 80's and 90's no longer exists. There are still some clear remnants of those genres. It's pretty clear what a "First Person Shooter" or "Fighting" game are. However, we have so many games, even from back then, that are hard to quantify in any one genre. Games like Zelda and Metroid have almost become genres in and of themselves. Furthermore, there are genre classifications that no longer quantify exactly what the experience may be like.
Case in point, the long running genre of "RPG" is too much of a blanket term anymore. Final Fantasy, Fallout, and Mass Effect all come to mind as games you could qualify as an RPG, but that's unfair and cheapens all of their experiences.
Final Fantasy is on one end of the spectrum, a purely story and character driven experience. You control the characters, but they still are who they are. You don't have much say in what they do outside of battle, except for maybe which path to take or who to talk to. Is it still a role playing game? Technically, yes. It uses systems found in the ancestor of D&D, but has changed and taken them into their own systems now, which get further and further away from their original inspiration with each passing iteration.
Fallout, 3 in particular, is on the other complete extreme opposite of the spectrum. You create your own character, breathe life into them, decide who they are what drives them and what you're going to do. It's a sandbox, you get a world to play in, and you get to decide who you are in this world. There is a story still, but it's generally more 'incidental' to the overall game. It's something that's there, but you're not penalized for not doing it, because you have other things that are far more interesting and in the forefront of your mind. Is it still an RPG? 3 could almost be argued as being a first person shooter, and could play out as such. All in all, however, you are playing a role, in a game. So it's more literal in it's interpretation.
Mass Effect, and other Bioware RPGs, are in their own classification as well. It's a mix of the two. You have the ability to create your character, to select how you're going to interact with a situation. The battle in earlier games was still very much dice rolling, (Especially in Neverwinter Nights and KOTOR). I understand they've moved away from that in Mass Effect 2, but that's just more of that innovation and separation from the original inspiration. Mass Effect, in contrast with Fallout 3, has a story that keeps you on track, directs where you go and when. So in all it's almost a hybrid between what Final Fantasy and Fallout do. More open than the sandbox, but not as restrictive as 100% story driven.
RPGs are only one example of a term that's no longer applicable, and I don't want to waste more of the article in trying to define all the differences in various genres. Instead, when a friend asks, "What game should I play?" I plan to ask the responding question, "Why do you play games?"
There are many good reasons to play games. I, myself, play games for various different reasons as well. Sometimes I focus more on having an 'experience'. Something that couldn't have been done in other games. Heavy Rain's a rather good example of a game that's more of an 'experience'. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories would also be more in that category, in my eyes. Some people play games competitively, which is more grounds for games like Call of Duty, or World of Warcraft, or even the Street Fighter series. There's also people that probably play games for the more all encompassing term "fun". I, too, play games for fun, which will more need a qualifying follow up question of what sort of games someone has fun with. For pure fun, I'd say look no further than Just Cause 2, or maybe even something like WET. There are times when you just wanna go through and mow down tons of people with ease, and I find those are both two very good experiences where you can do just that.
In closing, I point the question to you, users of GamerDNA: Why do you play games? If you'd like to, follow it up with some games that you would give as good examples of the 'why'.
The term RPG is not too far antiquated though. It is a genre and within that are subgenres. Just like there is Horror film and there are Zombie movies, which is why for RPGs there are JRPGS, MMORPGS, FPS-RPGS, or the ever familiar other genres with RPG elements.
I need to blow off some steam = MW2
I want to escape reality for a bit = Fallout 3
I want to explore and hang out with some friends online = WoW
I want to feel like a badass and mow down enemies by the hundreds = God of War
I just feel like rocking out = Rock Band / Guitar Hero
Looking for a bit of fun = South Park Let's Go Tower Defense Play / Geometry Wars
Needing control amid the chaos of life = The Sims/ Sim City/ Black and White
Feeling creative = The Movies
I wanna blow some shit up! = Mercs 2 / Just Cause 2
Feeling sneaky = Splinter Cell / Metal Gear Solid 4
Perhaps that's a thing of the past and doesn't happen as frequently, but there's still competition in every aspect of an MMO, needing the best skills, the best gear, the best builds.
Perhaps there are people that play it more casually, but when you boil down the very basic aspects to them, that's what the design goal in mind is for them. That's how they keep you paying for the monthly fee year after year.
And to what @rawkr said, I agree with the statement about RPGs. Almost every game is an RPG today, its the subtle differences that have it stand out. Many MMOs are competitive and PVP based, its the little experiences and features, social capability and capacity that effect the success of the game.
Sometimes I just want to screw around, see how much fun I can have, and see how I can outsmart people. Left 4 Dead seems like it was made for this.
Then there's like some sort of Zelda or Metroid mood I get into every few years, where I get nostalgic and want to play them again.
But that's just me.
However there have been some recent games which have kept me playing through them - Mass Effect; Fallout 3; Time Shift.
If in the first 30mins I am not hooked, then I'm sad to say I won't pick it up again. I can be very picky when it comes to games.